I enjoyed our visit the the archives and special collections. It was my first time being around a collection of books that old and rare and, I must admit, I was worried of accidentally ruining or breaking one of them. I enjoyed learning from the librarians about the different types of materials used to create and bind the books. Something I most appreciated about their lesson and lecture was the set-up of the room. I think it was helpful to have the materials sorted by location of origin. This helped me see trends in their binding and production styles. For example, at the east Asia table I noticed that many of the pieces used the stab stitch binding. This binding method reminded me of how I used to bind school projects, such as poetry packets, that we were assigned to turn into books. My main takeaway from this lesson was the extensive range of materials, design, and production styles used to share written works. I learned about the progression from scrolls to accordion folds, to codexes and the benefits to each. I also learned about many materials that were used as paper that I hadn't known about. These ranged from plant-based resources such as rice paper, papyrus, plant pulp, and tree pulp to natural resources such as clay, stone, and animal hides.
I also learned that something being an old, rare copy instead of the original source itself doesn't necessarily make it less valuable. I feel like I had the idea that anything that isn't the exact original source isn't nearly as valuable as what could be considered the "real deal" or the original text that was written on by its author. However, I learned about the benefits of copies, one of the most important of which is preservation. Copies allow text to be preserved; if an original text is ruined, copies allow the text and its content to live on. I could go into more detail about what else I liked about this class session, but these are the main topics that I enjoyed learning about!
Hey Audrey! I was terrified I was going to break something the whole time too. I also didn't know that copies could still be extremely valuable. I mean, if you think about it, one day these copies will become extremely old and could be seen as basically original texts.
ReplyDeleteHey Audrey, I agree, I loved the setup of the room. It made it so much easier for me to navigate and see the history of the book based on region. I think learning about the different formats and history of the book was fascinating too; I had no idea there were so many different forms of "paper"!
ReplyDeleteHi Audrey! I had the same feeling walking into the room and wasn't sure if I was actually allowed to touch any of it. Usually with old and rare things people aren't too keen on having people touch it and potentially ruin it. I never really put into context stab sticking binding in today's world, but I would have to agree that I also did that with some of my projects. I actually used to think that copies has a major decrease in value compared to the original. I never realized that they would actually be so expensive. Thank you for sharing your perspective! :)
ReplyDeleteHey Audrey! Like other comments have mentioned, I also was paranoid that I was going to ruin one of the exhibit pieces! Thankfully, we made it, and I was able to appreciate the different types of materials and bindings you mentioned. Speaking of surprise about the value of non-original copies, I was also shocked when I realized a mistake in a copy, such as a typo or an extra word, could also increase its value! I'm not so sure I would pay more to own a copy with one extra word, would you?
ReplyDeleteHey Audrey! I agree about feeling worried that I may ruin something. The tiny books, in particular, felt extremely fragile in my hands. I thought your opinions on copies of older texts was interesting. I believe that copies are valuable, too! However, I do think making them so expensive is a bit silly! What's the point of a copy if it's going to be as exclusive as the original! It was nice to see all the texts in a form that is closer to when they were originally created, though.
ReplyDeleteI totally agree that it was a little nerve racking to be in that room with such old expensive texts. To be completely honest I couldn't bring myself to touch any of them for fear that I would be too clumsy and mess something up. It is an interesting line with old books between wanting to preserve them and wanting to gain knowledge from them. What's the point of having these old books if you cannot interact with them, but will that interaction cost future generations the experience of this book?
ReplyDeleteHey Audrey! I also used to think that any kind of copy of a book could not be as valuable as the original! It really surprised me to hear all of the work that was put into making replicas of those classic works of art. However, it made me feel that every generation is welcome to create their own interpretations of texts to keep them alive.
ReplyDeleteI think you are exactly right--is stories survive, it's because people find ways to make them meaningful, even in very new and different time periods and/or locations.
DeleteI also appreciate how they set up the exhibit of books. It was really cool to see how books evolved within geographies, and how different geographical regions developed books. It allowed us to make broader comparisons in books materials and forms.
ReplyDelete